Archivists Workshop - Shire Hall, Hereford,
September 7th, 2002
Third Workshop
Collections and Classification of Archives
Paper presented by Peter J.H.
Avon South Intergroup
and South Midlands Regional Archivist (Alternate)
The collecting of AA archives was started by our co-founder Bill W.
less than twenty years after the founding of our Fellowship. Bill had the
foresight and the vision to see we needed to preserve an historical record
of our movements origins so that "myth does not predominate over fact."
It is possible to trace this back to June 1949 and chart correspondence
between Bill and Jack Alexander, the author of the famous 1941 Saturday
Evening Post article. Bill wanted Jack Alexander to do a follow-up
article in order for him to record the rapid changes then happening in the
Fellowship. Jack was unwilling to do this so soon; only nine years since
his last look at AA. Jack thought not much had changed to justify another
look: that the psychology of drinkers was the same, and AAs method of
dealing with alcoholics was also unchanged. Bill disagreed and told him
that with the introduction of the 12 Traditions, Alcoholics Anonymous was
like no other society on earth; that there was much new material for him
to consider, albeit most of it was still in Bills head, but that there was
enough new material there to form the basis for a new article.
But even before this time Bill was aware of the need to record events as
he encouraged Lois to keep a journal and a copy of all their
correspondence. However, it was from 1950 that Bill and Nell Wing (his
secretary) really concerned themselves with obtaining and preserving
historical records. While from 1950 to 1954 Bill was writing the 12&12 he
was also collecting oral histories from old-timers in Akron and Cleveland.
Bill would travel out West specifically to record these people something
which shows how much importance he gave to archival work. He also set
about recording the recollections of the Trustees, the members of staff at
the office like Ruth Hock and the non-alcoholic clergymen who had played
such a vital part in establishing AA.
As an example on the 23rd of February 1955, Bill wrote to Clarence S. in
Cleveland asking him to record his recollections, and this gives an
accurate insight into the methods and purpose of archives.
"I would like to have you make a tape recording about your
recollections of the old days. There isnt any rush about this as the
preparation of a history will have to be done carefully and gradually over
the next 2 or 3 years. I have though made a couple of trips to Akron and
Cleveland and have already interviewed quite a lot of the old folks, so as
to be sure and get the record straight. You can get a good running start
at the history by retelling your own personal story how AA came to your
attention; what your first impressions were and how it developed in the
first few years in Cleveland. I hope you can dwell at length on the
difficulties as well as the humour of those years, relating as many
anecdotes as possible. You can say anything you like being assured that
nothing will be published without your consent. The preliminary
investigation shows that it isnt hard to prepare a fact, what happened,
that is dates when people came in, groups started and so forth. The hard
thing is to lay hold of the atmosphere of the whole proceedings and the
anecdotal material that will make the early experience live. When I first
set out to gather material I ran into a little resistance. I pointed out
to them that if the old-timers in Akron and Cleveland wouldnt go on record
as to what happened, how in Gods name could I or anyone else tell an
accurate story for the future. Clarence, I feel that you should be one of
those very best sources. So think it over. Make an outline of topics that
you want to talk about and go to it at any length at all -- recording
tapes are cheap. So ransack your memory if you will."
In 1955 Bill appointed Nell Wing as Archivist and as the oral
histories began to pour into the office between 1955 and 1960 Nell found
herself with just one of many ongoing projects she had to do. In 1965 she
did manage to make a small beginning on classification but it was not
until after Bills death in 1971 that Nell really got down to serious
archival activity. In particular, she received encouragement from a member
down in Florida, Tom S., who kept encouraging her to keep going when
others thought she was creating a monster. It seemed now the time for
archives had finally come and an Archive Committee was formed in 1973. In
1975 an archive office at GSO was officially opened by Lois and it is
worth remembering that even archivists are not perfect as nobody that day
thought to record Loiss words.
In 1980 at the World Convention in New Orleans two English members came
away from Nells early morning workshop on archives determined to start
something similar in England. On return they obtained a copy of the
guidelines and contacted the General Secretary in London and their local
Intergroup inviting them to join with them in this new form of service but
there is no record of a reply being received. So they set up a small
archive committee within their own group. Its remit was simple: to see
what was out there, and if anything, was it worth recording?
What happened next was amazing! They were given Press cuttings and
photographs of AA in the West Country from the early days. A member loaned
the committee over a 1000 letters written by Sackville detailing many of
the important events and of people in Englands history. For instance, did
you know Sackville convened an AA public meeting in Cardiff in 1950 after
first refereeing an International sports match?
The little committee then received an audio tape from probably the first
Al-Anon member in Europe whos husband had been an early AA member in the
West of England. The tape charted the first AA meetings at Mickleton,
Evesham, Cheltenham and Bath during the
first 15 years. They then received a tape of the founder of AA in Bristol
which led to even more valuable research being done in that City. It is
worth remembering that two of the oldest and most active members in the
West Country both got sober in the same group
in Washington, DC.
In 1985 Nell Wing came to the Bristol Reunion and convened an archives
meeting. Staff from service offices in Britain and Ireland attended,
something which became the launch pad for them to display their own
national archives. One last thing about Nell; she was a great one for
encouraging oral histories and she said: "as archivists we should never go
anywhere without tape recorders..." .
Bristol is fortunate to have had an exceptional member in its groups who
had the foresight to record what was happening in the Fellowship at home
and abroad, particularly from 1968 onwards through the unofficial AA
journal, Bristol Fashion: dates of events, conventions, workshops,
gatherings etc., the opening of new groups, recording the deaths of
old-timers, articles and observations on our AA life, all written by
members themselves and with plenty of anecdotes to liven things up. It
also makes up something of a "spiritual soap opera" due to its length of
publication and the fact that it became a means for keeping members in
touch with each other from around the world. Bristol Fashion is as yet an
untapped primary source of information on the growth and depth of our
Fellowship.
It was through an idea given by one of the readers of Bristol Fashion that
led to the First European Convention of Alcoholics Anonymous in Bristol in
1971 and convened by the South West Intergroup, SWIG for short! Most of
the earliest members in Britain and Europe attended this event as did a
whole host of GSO staff and Trustees from New York and London. It also
brought AA to the attention of the Vatican through the attendance of
Archbishop Enricci as a guest and who was afforded a full diplomatic
welcome to the City for the express purpose of attending the European
Convention. Another often overlooked fact in England is the role of
clergymen in helping to establish AA. This is an area that needs much more
research.
The exceptional Bristol member had the foresight also to keep all his
correspondence with the early members in England and some in North
America. The archive contains something like 15000 items of correspondence
worth preserving: something approaching 500 tapes, on which all the talks
have actually been heard in person: there is information on the formation
and work of the service structure in England over the last four decades.
Also in the archive is a library of AA books: all Alcoholics Anonymous
hard back books known as "the family books," mostly first editions, many
subsequent editions inscribed by a few authors/editors, AA friends and AA
archivists past and present. There are early printings of four first
editions of the Big Book, Alcoholics Anonymous, which the archive has
either inherited from the owner or has had donated. There is regret in our
Region that the 2nd edition Big Book inscribed by Bill himself to Frank of
Calne could not somehow have stayed in the Regional Archives. Yet on
further consideration, having this particular treasure securely housed in
the National Archives is the very safest place for it.
There is also a huge contribution of alcoholism-related books written on
psychology, medicine and spirituality. The library contains in all
approximately 560 books as well as numerous booklets and early pamphlets.
You may ask the question, should we as AA archivists collect anything
other than AA documents? Bill answers this question in a letter to Milton
Maxwell who first drew Bills attention to the story of the Washingtonians.
"I am extremely glad that such a thorough going study as yours has been
made available. Here and there I have noted other attempts but nothing at
all comparable to what you have done. I wish every AA could indelibly burn
the history of the Washingtonians in his memory. It is an outstanding
example of how and how not we ought to conduct ourselves. In a sense AA
has never had a problem seriously threatening our overall unity. Yet I
notice some AAs are complacent enough we never shall. You have certainly
done your bit to rectify that condition."
In the archive is an original Hansard copy of an Act of Parliament, put
through from a Private Members Bill in 1986 by Sir Bernard Braine, M.P.
who was a good friend of Alcoholics Anonymous. This Act was needed to keep
AA within the law of the land, because at the time it found itself in
breach of a new Charities Act, by adhering to our Tradition of self
support, through not accepting nor soliciting outside contributions,
which, with its charitable status, it was obliged to do. So rather than
change Alcoholics Anonymous in any way, AA had the wisdom and the courage
to have the law changed instead. This all provided our Fellowship with
lots of good and incredulous attention from the media.
A part of the archive includes extensive records and much memorabilia of a
particular group which has been in continuous existence for over thirty
years and many of the items on our National Committee Chairmans list of
collectables are in fact already in this group archive. This is because
although the founder died some twelve years ago, the first secretary of
the group -- a veritable magpie -- is still alive and attending meetings
in the very same venue and apparently has never thrown anything away! One
of the ways this group has chosen to carry the message is to reconvene in
1981 the annual convention, known as the AA Reunion in Bristol. Here again
there is a detailed record of speakers and the organization and of each
Reunion and especially of how much fun they always have. In their files is
a balance sheet of each event, a copy of which was always lodged at GSO
right up until the current era began in the early nineties. This is very
impressive and was very much in line with the openness and availability of
the Reunion records and accounts.
As regards ownership of the Archive which has been in the possession of
the archivist for many years, it is considered that all straightforward
and factual items, such as the original material covering the start of
Alcoholics Anonymous in the West Country, including the diary of Bristols
founding member, together with a copy of an original 24-hour meditation
book which has notes at the back on the formation of Bristols second
group, "belong to AA" as we say. Some of the "family books" and three of
the four first editions of the Big Book would fall into this category as
well, two printed in the States and one in England! Reunion files and much
else besides would also "belong to AA." Three current members of the
original archives committee have been invited to act as trustees and
custodians of the Archive to fulfill the role of AA in the event of the
archivists death. All other items, that would never ever be displayed
would become the property of the Archivists grown-up children but would
remain in the archive and under the custodianship of the trustees. Two
stipulations have been made, however. Firstly, that the Archive is never
to be broken up and, secondly, that whatever happens to it and whatever
the custodians wish to do with it (for example, whether to close the
archive or continue working on it) all five trustees must be in unanimous
agreement.
The current work on the Archive has been to build on what has already been
there for over twenty years and the hope and expectation is that others
will come along to help continue the work. My job over the last three
years has been to fulfill the late Barbara Ts request that the archive be
indexed and to classify what there was. This was not difficult as the
nature of the material makes for its own classification. The way ahead is
having to scan everything onto disc in order to preserve it. Over time
pages are fading especially Jim Hs diary entries of the first couple of
years or so of the start of AA in Bristol The archivists home group also
helps out on a regular basis and the Intergroup has voted a nominal sum
per month for archive work, it is hoped shortly to be received.
Though very rewarding, it is time consuming work and not many people as
yet want to give up their spare time to go leafing through old papers. But
it is being done and the index runs to hundreds of pages. So it is with
great hope for the future of archives we attend this event today and say
that although much of the groundwork has already been done there is much
more to do, for as Frank M. said, "Archives is our window on the past,
guide to the present, and light for the future."
This is the end of my paper. Thank you very much for listening.
* * *
Sources: Nell Wings talks at the Reunion in Bristol 1985
Judit Santons talk at the National Archives Convention, Seattle, 2000
The Archivist, Avon South Intergroup and South Midlands Region